• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The Readers and Writers Paradise

The real scoop on middle grade books.

  • Home
  • About
  • Audio Stories
  • Contact Me
  • Archives

the black circle

The 39 Clues Book 5: The Black Circle by Patrick Carman Review

February 6, 2014 by Daniel Johnston 3 Comments

As usual, I was really excited to read the fifth book in The 39 Clues series, The Black Circle by Patrick Carman. After a wayward third book, the fourth book had been relatively strong and the fifth book was looking to be exciting by all indications. There were some promos and sneak peaks for it during the summer that were pretty well done, and I’m happy to say the book didn’t disappoint.

The 39 Clues, for those who don’t know, is a multi-author series about two kids named Dan and Amy Cahill. Amy and Dan learn that they are members of the most powerful family in human history when their grandmother, Grace, dies. The source of their families power is in thirty-nine chemical elements, and whoever assembles them all will become the most powerful person ever.

Of course, Amy and Dan are not the only people looking after the clues. Their conniving relatives are also after them, and will do anything to find them. Even kill.

The 39 Clues also tends to be good for learning history because Amy and Dan travel the world to all kinds of exciting places. Paris, Venice, Cairo, and, in this book, Russia.

If you haven’t read the series yet, I’d start with the most recent series and then work your way back from the first book. For those of you who have…

Summary

Amy and Dan are still in their hotel room in Egypt when they get a telegram from a person who calls himself (or herself) NRR. NRR gives them an airport locker number. The telegram also contains a poem about how Dan buried his bottle cap collection in Grace’s yard, making Amy and Dan think NRR must have known Grace.

Their au pair Nellie is asleep, so they head out without her and leave a message. In this book much more than any of the others, Amy and Dan act independently without Nellie’s help.

Of course, things won’t go so easy for Amy and Dan that they can just get to the airport easily. Ian and Natalie Kabra, their rich cousins, are already on their tail. Amy and Dan manage to outsmart them, however, and find a key hidden in a glass paperweight and a piece of paper with jumbled letters on it. They also get disguises, passports, a credit card (which Dan is most excited about), and a Russian guide book with plane tickets. Most important to Amy and Dan: A picture of their late parents in Russia.

Even though Nellie is still in the hotel room, time is of the essence and they head out. Dan decodes the piece of paper to be various cities in Russia. Amy and Dan learn that the clue may have something to do with Anastasia Romanov and her medicine man, Rasputin.

They scale all the to the top of The Motherland Calls Statue to find a clue, but meet up with the Holt family. Dan decides to team up with Hamilton because he knows that there’s no way they can to all the cities on the list in time. It is a very exciting book and they do all kinds of awesome things, too many to list here.

They are also tracked down by Irina Spasky, an ex-KGB agent. Irina tries to convince them not to look for the clue, but the pictures of their parents and the connection to Grace make Amy and Dan forge on.

Will Amy and Dan make it in time to see NRR? More importantly; will NRR actually help them, or simply kill them?

Review

This is an awesome book, one of the best in the series. It is very clearly written and I still remember a lot of the historical information in the book. It is very fast-paced and full of adventure. Carman did a great job.

Even though it’s not quite written in the same style as the earlier books, I think this one is just as good. The characters also develop well, as we see Amy and Dan going off on their own. We also meet NRR and get closer to the Holt family, seeing a better side of them. In addition, we see that Irina cares about Amy and Dan because she doesn’t kill them when she has the chance.

If I was going to rate The 39 Clues books, this would be a strong contender for the best one; I can’t even think of anything bad to say about it. It’s too bad that this is the only book Carman wrote in the series.

Thank you for reading this review and if you’d like to purchase the book you can do so through this link. You can also like my Facebook page or subscribe through email below.

Enter your email address:

Filed Under: Patrick Carman, The 39 Clues Tagged With: patrick carman, The 39 clues, the 39 clues the black circle, the black circle, the black circle by patrick carman, the black circle by patrick carman review, the black circle by patrick carman summary

Primary Sidebar

About Me!
Follow @kidwriters


Hi, I'm Daniel Johnston. I'm a seventeen year-old who loves everything about books! Check around for book reviews, recordings of audio short stories, and my own writing. Thanks for stopping by!

Recent Posts

  • Requeim
  • Stanley and Katrina by Felicia Maziarz Review
  • Interview with 13 Year Old Author Tate Linders! Podcast #12
  • Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck Review
  • An Objective Standard for Books?

Archives

  • February 2019
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • August 2012
  • April 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012

The Best Authors. The Best Books.

Gordon Korman
The 39 Clues
Swindle Series

Contact Me!

    Your Name (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Subject

    Your Message

    Confirm you're a real person (required)

    Copyright © 2025 · Genesis Sample on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in